Related videos:
A man from Florida was arrested for an unusual case of multiple bigamy, after it was discovered that he was married to three women at the same time in different counties of the state. The accused, identified as Henry Betsey Jr., faces felony charges of bigamy, according to a report by ABC Action News.
For two years, Betsey Jr. managed to maintain parallel marriages with three women, Tonya, Brandi, and Michele Betsey, without any of them knowing about the others. Each relationship started through different dating apps such as Tinder, Stir, and Match.com.
Tonya married Henry in November 2020. Brandi married in February 2022, and Michele in November of that same year.
The accused took them to get married in different counties, which allowed him to evade detection by the authorities regarding the other legal unions. According to the affected parties, the system failed spectacularly.
"If the counties had spoken up, it would have saved me a lot of pain, money, and stress", Tonya told ABC Action News.
With the passage of time, women began to suspect that Henry's motivations were more financial than emotional.
“The day we got married, he said: ‘We need to turn your bank account into a joint account,’” Brandi recalled.
"Child support, alimony, everything that entails... the additional advantages of marrying a recently single and divorced woman," Michele explained.
According to statements made in a recent court hearing, Henry has no income or money in the bank, and is currently living with a "Christian friend."
In addition to emotional deception and potential fraud, Henry was accused of abusive behaviors. Michele and Tonya obtained restraining orders for domestic violence, while Brandi kicked him out of her house just five days after their wedding.
The case came to light when Tonya researched Henry's name in county civil records, uncovering his other marriages. Michele, upon finding out, went to the Hernando County authorities, which led to the investigation that resulted in his arrest.
According to Ken Burke, the Pinellas County Clerk, Florida allows for the easy formalization of civil marriages, which, in cases like this, can help prevent abuses of the system.
"We got married right there in the courthouse, no questions asked. There was no issue with the system, even though I already had two active marriages," Michele recounted.
Burke warned that without a national marriage registry, it is nearly impossible to prevent transient individuals from marrying multiple times without leaving a trace in other states.
After his arrest, Henry filed for divorce from Tonya and is seeking the annulment of his marriages to Michele and Brandi. He has pleaded not guilty to the charge of bigamy and is required to appear before a judge again later this month.
Meanwhile, the three wives are waiting for justice to take action and for the case to be used to review the legal gaps that allowed this scheme to go undetected for so long.
"There is a possibility that he might simply be released on parole. And that is what is truly painful: there is no accountability," Michele concluded.
Frequently Asked Questions about the Bigamy Case in Florida
Who is Henry Betsey Jr. and why was he arrested in Florida?
Henry Betsey Jr. is a man from Florida arrested for multiple bigamy, as he was simultaneously married to three women in different counties of the state. The case was uncovered when one of his wives researched his name in the civil records of several counties.
How did Henry Betsey Jr. manage to marry three women without being discovered?
Henry Betsey Jr. avoided being discovered by marrying in different counties in Florida, which prevented the authorities from detecting the simultaneous marriages due to the lack of a national marriage registry. This allowed him to maintain three parallel relationships without any of his wives knowing about the others.
What were Henry Betsey Jr.'s motivations for maintaining multiple marriages?
Henry Betsey Jr.'s motivations seemed to be financial, as he sought to take advantage of benefits such as joint bank accounts, child support, and alimony. His wives began to suspect his intentions after noticing his interest in financial matters.
What legal consequences does Henry Betsey Jr. face for his actions?
Henry Betsey Jr. faces felony charges of bigamy and will have to appear before a judge. Additionally, his wives have obtained restraining orders for domestic violence, and some have filed for divorce or annulment of their marriages with him.
What measures could be taken to prevent similar cases of bigamy in the future?
The creation of a national marriage registry could prevent cases of bigamy like that of Henry Betsey Jr. Ken Burke, the Pinellas County Clerk, noted that the ease of getting married in Florida without proper checks allows individuals to marry multiple times without being detected in other states.
Filed under: