
A U.S. federal judge rejected on Tuesday the request from the Government of Donald Trump to suspend the order that requires him to confidentially disclose who consulted the legal memorandum supporting military attacks on vessels suspected of drug trafficking in the Caribbean and the Pacific, when they did so, and for what purpose.
The magistrate Paul Engelmayer, from the Southern District Court of New York, issued the order in the context of the litigation that seeks to make public a memorandum prepared by the Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) of the Department of Justice in September 2025.
According to the resolution, the Government must provide the court, confidentially, with the identity of those who accessed the document, the dates of access, and the purpose of each inquiry.
The Executive has 14 days to meet that requirement.
The document in question analyzes the legal authority of the president to order lethal attacks—including potential drone strikes—against boats allegedly linked to drug trafficking.
The case was brought forward by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), the NYCLU, and the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), who requested the memorandum under the Freedom of Information Act in October 2025 and, in light of the Government's silence, filed a lawsuit in December of that year.
This is not the first time Judge Engelmayer has pressured the Executive on this matter: at the end of September 2026, he had already issued a 66-page ruling ordering the government to submit the memorandum for private judicial review, rejecting the Justice Department's arguments for keeping it completely hidden.
The court argued that the Department of Defense and Southern Command (SOUTHCOM) had adopted the reasoning of the memorandum as the operational "legal framework" for the campaign, which weakened the argument that it was merely an internal advisory document.
The campaign of attacks, known as Operation Southern Spear or "Spear of the South," was launched in August-September 2025 under a presidential directive that authorized the use of lethal force against foreign criminal groups involved in drug trafficking.
Since the first documented attack—on September 2, 2025, against a Venezuelan vessel allegedly carrying members of the Tren de Aragua—this campaign has sparked intense legal and human rights controversy.
At the one-year mark of operations, the EFE agency reported at least 227 dead, 68 vessels destroyed and only three documented survivors.
According to an updated report from InSight Crime on October 5, 2026, the attacks had left at least 238 dead across 79 operations, with the government providing no public evidence that all the victims were drug traffickers.
The Trump administration has labeled the occupants of the attacked vessels as "narco-terrorists," but the suing organizations argue that the OLC memorandum should be made public so that the public can assess whether these attacks have sufficient legal backing.
The new order from Judge Engelmayer seeks to determine whether the Executive can continue to invoke any form of legal privilege over the document, or whether the extent of its operational use necessitates its disclosure.
Related videos:
Filed under: