
Four legal aid organizations for immigrants filed a federal lawsuit in the Massachusetts District Court this Wednesday to compel the government to disclose the whereabouts of tens of thousands of individuals detained by ICE with final deportation orders, whose locations were removed from the public search system in September.
The case, registered as Greater Boston Legal Services et al. v. Mullin, number 1:26-cv-14869, was filed by Greater Boston Legal Services, Rian Immigrant Center, Florence Immigrant and Refugee Rights Project, and Amica Center for Immigrant Rights, with the support of the National Immigration Law Center, the National Immigration Project, the ACLU, and the ACLU of Massachusetts.
The lawsuit challenges the so-called "ODLS Final Order Policy," adopted around September 15 without public announcement or notification to detainees or their attorneys, under which ICE stopped displaying the locations of individuals with administratively final deportation orders on its online locator.
According to the alleged data, in July 2026, there was an average of 66,904 people daily in immigration custody, of which approximately 21,700 —nearly 32%— had final orders and were excluded from the system from the very first day of the policy's implementation.
The policy also includes, according to the plaintiffs, explicit instructions to ICE agents to refuse to disclose the location of affected individuals when lawyers or family members request it by phone.
The only exceptions are the detainees at the Adelanto center in California and in temporary facilities in Minneapolis, New York, and the suburbs of Chicago, where previous court orders require ICE to keep them visible.
The locator, created in June 2010 and available in 11 languages 24 hours a day, was described by the agency upon its launch as "a public service, especially for relatives and legal representatives, to help locate individuals arrested for administrative immigration violations."
Organizations report that alternative mechanisms are ineffective: calls to field offices result in long waits and disconnections, the detention information hotline only operates Monday through Friday and its operators consult the same system that no longer displays the data, and the ERO eFile program covers only about 46 centers out of the hundreds in use.
"Nobody should be deprived of a meaningful opportunity to defend their rights because the government has made it impossible for their lawyer to find them," stated Jacquelynne Bowman, executive director of Greater Boston Legal Services. "This arbitrary administrative change puts hundreds of thousands of people at risk of facing life-altering consequences without essential legal assistance."
The lawsuit alleges three violations: the Administrative Procedure Act, for abandoning 16 years of established practice without a reasoned explanation; the First Amendment, for blocking communication between attorneys and clients; and the Freedom of Information Act, for failing to make the directive's text public.
The Department of Homeland Security has not publicly confirmed the change, but it issued a statement gathered by AP in response to the lawsuit: "Illegal aliens in detention have various ways to communicate with their family members and lawyers. The proper process for an illegal alien with final deportation orders is expulsion, nothing more."
The case has direct implications for families and lawyers trying to locate detainees, including Cubans: the lawsuit cites the case of Noslén Sendra, a Cuban detained in Krome North (Miami), regarding a ruling in which a judge warned that the policy hinders the courts' ability to determine their jurisdiction and obstructs family members and lawyers from locating the detainees.
On September 30, 47 congress members sent a letter to the acting director of ICE, David Venturella, demanding the reversal of the policy and the delivery of the directive text before October 14; according to the lawsuit, Venturella did not respond.
Related videos:
Filed under: