The property tax cut that Florida voters approved on Tuesday, November 3, could increase another expense that is already burdensome for homeowners: homeowners insurance.
This is warned by an analysis published by Bloomberg and reproduced by Insurance Journal, which identifies a little-discussed side effect of Amendment 3.
The measure, championed by Governor Ron DeSantis, expands the current homestead tax exemption from $50,000 to $150,000 in 2027 and to $250,000 in 2028, without affecting the taxes allocated for public schools.
It also lowers the annual cap on the assessed value increase for non-homestead properties from 10% to 5%. The problem is that this tax relief comes at a cost: local governments will lose billions of dollars in revenue.
Florida TaxWatch, a non-partisan fiscal research organization, estimates that counties, cities, and special districts will incur losses of approximately 45.8 billion dollars over the first five years, with an impact that could reach 11.86 billion annually by 2031-2032.
That budget cut is where the risk for insurance comes in. Insurers use the ratings from the Insurance Services Office (ISO) to assess the fire response capability of each community.
If a municipality reduces firefighters, equipment, or shifts, its fire protection classification could deteriorate, which may result in higher premiums for all property owners in that area.
"A decrease in fire protection services in a community can lead to a lower ISO rating," explained Mark Friedlander, spokesperson for the Insurance Information Institute.
"The ISO rating is one of the many risk factors that insurers use to underwrite homes in Florida and could potentially lead to an increase in premiums if the rating decreases."
Dunedin, a small city in Pinellas County, has already developed a contingency plan that includes reducing the number of firefighters per shift and cutting specialized training for emergency personnel.
The city is projected to lose $4.7 million in the fiscal year 2028 and $7.6 million annually starting in 2029, although authorities have not yet approved these reductions.
In South Florida, the outlook is equally concerning. Miami-Dade estimates a revenue reduction of about 386 million dollars in the first year and 697 million in the second.
Hialeah is considering cutting municipal salaries by up to 20% for non-union employees, including civilian staff of the Police and Fire departments.
Jesse Keenan, a professor of sustainable real estate and urban planning at Tulane University, clearly summarizes the dilemma: “You’re essentially going to pay to live in a high-risk area, either as a taxpayer or as a fee payer. It’s simply shifting the burden.”
Keenan also warns that tighter budgets will mean fewer resources for construction inspectors and disaster mitigation programs, which will “greatly harm the ability of local governments to invest in risk reduction.”
For Cuban homeowners in Miami-Dade, the balance is a double-edged sword. County property appraiser, Tomás Regalado, estimated average savings of $1,700 in 2027 and $2,700 in 2028 for eligible homeowners.
The reform includes an important limitation for those arriving in Florida starting in 2027. New residents will be eligible for the basic tax exemption of $50,000, but they will have to wait until their fifth year with the homestead exemption to access the expanded benefit. This means that Cubans who establish residency in the state after December 31, 2026, will not be able to immediately enjoy the greater savings expected from Amendment 3.
However, that benefit could be undermined if insurance premiums rise as a result of decreased fire protection.
It is important to emphasize that the increase in premiums is a possible risk, not a confirmed fact. No insurance company has announced increases related to Amendment 3, and the process of reviewing ISO ratings takes time.
Florida is now the most expensive state in the country for homeowners insurance, with average premiums of about $8,471 annually for a coverage of $300,000, more than double the national average.
DeSantis announced that he will call a special legislative session before January 1, 2027, to implement the reform and prevent cities and counties from recouping lost revenue through new fees or charges, which would leave local governments with even less leeway to sustain their services.
Related videos:
Filed under: