The Florida Attorney General responds to Doral: breaking the agreement with ICE would violate the state law against sanctuary cities

Operation for the detention of a migrant (Reference image)Photo © Facebook/ICE

The Florida Attorney General, James Uthmeier, responded to the authorities in Doral with a legal opinion warning that canceling an existing immigration cooperation agreement with ICE, without sufficient justification, would likely violate state law against so-called sanctuary cities, complicating efforts to terminate the agreement that keeps the police of that city in Miami-Dade County.

The response was sent on Wednesday to Mayor Christi Fraga and is signed by Deputy Attorney General Greg Slemp, according to reported this Thursday by Florida's Voice.

The document addresses two central questions: whether municipalities are obligated to sign agreements for the federal program 287(g) and whether they can withdraw from those they have already signed.

The conclusion draws an important distinction between both situations. According to Slemp, refusing to sign a 287(g) agreement does not, by itself, constitute a violation of Florida laws, although it may serve as an indication of illegal sanctuary policy depending on the circumstances.

However, the criteria are more restrictive when a city has already signed the agreement. In that case, terminating it without sufficiently justified reasons could demonstrate, according to the Public Prosecution Service, that the municipal government is obstructing migration cooperation and is not making its best efforts to support federal authorities.

The interpretation is based on two provisions of Chapter 908 of the Florida laws. Article 908.103 prohibits sanctuary policies, while Article 908.104 requires state and local law enforcement agencies to use their best efforts to support the enforcement of federal immigration laws.

The opinion considers the possibility of exceptional circumstances that justify canceling an agreement. As an example, Slemp mentioned a police agency with just one or two officers, for which maintaining that collaboration could represent a disproportionate burden. However, he noted that Doral is not in that situation.

The pronouncement represents a significant obstacle for residents, merchants, and activists in Doral who have been demanding the end of the agreement for months, especially in a city with a large Venezuelan population and a substantial Cuban community.

The answer Doral was waiting for already exists

The position of the Prosecutor's Office was revealed just one day after the Doral City Council postponed the discussion on its collaboration with ICE, through a vote of four to one.

The motion presented by Deputy Mayor Rafael Pineyro conditioned the discussion on receiving the legal opinion requested by Fraga. Councilwoman Maureen Porras, who advocates for the review or cancellation of the agreement, was the only one to vote against the postponement.

"‘We should discuss it now,’ Porras said to the Miami Herald, disagreeing with the decision to postpone the matter again."

The mayor had requested guidance from Uthmeier weeks ago, and both are scheduled to meet in early December.

The response signed by Slemp outlines a negative stance on canceling the agreement, although the meeting could still be used to discuss its implications and the options available to the municipality.

The legal opinion does not constitute a new law or a binding judicial ruling. It is the interpretation of the Attorney General regarding state laws that are already in effect.

However, the precedents in other cities in Florida indicate that such an interpretation can put considerable pressure on municipal officials.

Municipal lawyer Lorenzo Cobiella had previously warned that even discussing the termination of the agreement could expose the city and its council members to potential legal consequences.

Immigrant advocacy organizations hold a different interpretation. Sam Lester from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Florida has argued that municipalities can voluntarily abandon these agreements and has questioned whether the governor has the authority to remove officials simply for making that decision.

The controversy lies in the fact that the legislation of Florida explicitly requires participation in the 287(g) program for county detention center officials, but does not explicitly impose that same obligation on all municipal police departments.

What does it mean for Cubans and Venezuelans in Doral?

For immigrant families in Doral, Uthmeier's response reduces the likelihood that local authorities will cancel the agreement without facing a conflict with the state government.

However, it does not mean that the immigration rules changed this Thursday or that the municipal police have automatically begun to exercise new powers.

In fact, Doral acknowledges that none of its agents have yet received the necessary training to operate under the 287(g) program, despite the fact that the city approved its participation in April 2025 and formalized the agreement in January 2026.

"Last year we were advised to approve the agreement, and we did, but our agents have not received training for that purpose," admitted Vice Mayor Pineyro during the municipal discussion.

The 287(g) program allows certain local police officers, after receiving training and federal authorization, to perform specific immigration enforcement functions under the supervision of ICE.

For Cubans with I-220A documents, Venezuelans with parole (temporary stay permit), and other immigrants with pending processes, the legal opinion does not, by itself, change their individual immigration status.

The existence of the agreement must be distinguished from the powers that ICE already has to carry out federal operations.

Even if Doral were to cancel its participation in the program, federal agents could continue making arrests and conducting other immigration actions in the city, within the powers granted to them by U.S. law.

This difference was recognized by Pineyro, who warned that breaking the municipal agreement would not prevent ICE from continuing to operate in Doral.

The controversy also has consequences for the relationship between residents and local authorities. Adelys Ferro, executive director of the Venezuelan American Caucus, expressed during the town hall meeting that many people are afraid to call the police due to the possibility of becoming involved in an immigration procedure.

Merchants are also reporting losses. The Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of South Florida has estimated a decline in sales between 40% and 45% for businesses in the area, while individual establishments have reported even greater reductions amid the fear generated by immigration operations.

In October, activists and merchants publicly urged Doral to reconsider its agreement with ICE, arguing that the fear of arrests was negatively impacting both family life and the economic activity of the city.

Uthmeier also warns Tallahassee

The Florida Attorney General used the opinion sent to Doral on Thursday to issue a warning to Tallahassee, where municipal commissioners unanimously voted on Wednesday to examine the procedure that would allow them to terminate their own 287(g) agreement.

The Tallahassee vote did not cancel the agreement; rather, it allowed for the matter to be included in an upcoming meeting to examine both the exit procedure and its potential legal consequences.

In a message posted on X, Uthmeier reminded that his office had informed Doral that withdrawing from a 287(g) agreement could demonstrate the existence of prohibited sanctuary policies and a lack of sufficient efforts to support the enforcement of federal immigration laws.

"Supporting our federal partners and protecting our sovereignty is not optional, it is the law," stated the Attorney General.

The mayor of Tallahassee, Jeremy Matlow, has questioned that interpretation and argues that state law did not explicitly require his city to enter into the agreement. Commissioner Dianne Williams-Cox, for her part, warned about the potential penalties they could face if they decide to cancel it.

The dispute reflects the differences between the state government and several municipalities regarding the limits of police cooperation with ICE.

The precedents of Key West and Fort Myers

State pressure on cities that are trying to distance themselves from the 287(g) program has already led to changes in decisions in other municipalities in Florida.

In March 2025, the Fort Myers City Council initially rejected an agreement with ICE, but reversed its decision and approved it unanimously after receiving warnings from Uthmeier about potential sanctions, including the removal of officials.

Something similar happened in Key West. In June 2025, its commissioners voted to end police collaboration with ICE, but reversed their position following threats of legal consequences and dismissals made by state authorities.

The cases of Fort Myers and Key West illustrate the political and legal pressure that municipalities may face when challenging these agreements, although the legality of each decision depends on its circumstances and may be scrutinized by the courts.

Related videos:

Filed under:

CiberCuba Editorial Team

A team of journalists committed to reporting on Cuban current affairs and topics of global interest. At CiberCuba, we work to deliver truthful news and critical analysis.

CiberCuba Editorial Team

A team of journalists committed to reporting on Cuban current affairs and topics of global interest. At CiberCuba, we work to deliver truthful news and critical analysis.