Residents with a Green Card face detentions upon returning to the U.S. due to old criminal records: a warning for Cubans

American Airlines planes (Reference image)Photo © Wikimedia

An investigation by the Washington Post published on Tuesday, November 17, revealed a concerning pattern for immigrant communities: ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents are detaining permanent residents upon their return from trips abroad for charges or convictions from years or even decades ago that previously did not prevent them from obtaining or renewing their green card.

One of the documented cases is that of San Juanita Guerra, who had been crossing into Mexico from South Texas for three decades to fill medical prescriptions without any issues.

In March 2026, upon returning through a border port, the agents took his fingerprints and found a conviction from 1994 for illegally carrying a weapon.

She had paid a fine, briefly fulfilled probation, and renewed her green card three times. She remained detained for 22 days until an immigration judge authorized her release on bail.

The report also documents the death of Emiliano Andrade Covarrubias, a 56-year-old resident of Dallas, who was detained in June upon returning from Mexico.

ICE stated that he obtained his residency in 2019 without disclosing a theft record from 2004, a case that ended in deferred adjudication.

However, her daughter Estefani Andrade stated that her father had indeed informed about that file during the immigration process.

Andrade Covarrubias died in custody in Laredo on October 17 and was the seventh person to die while being held by ICE in Texas in 2026, according to The Texas Tribune.

Este tipo de detenciones al regreso de viajes es parte de un panorama migratorio en constante cambio. Sigue la cobertura completa en nuestra sección de para estar al tanto de todo lo que puede afectar tu estatus migratorio.

The Texas border lawyer Jaime Diez stated to the Post that he has handled at least 100 cases of this nature in the 18 months leading up to the publication. The Department of Homeland Security did not provide the newspaper with official figures on how many permanent residents have been detained under these circumstances.

The legal framework that enables these arrests

The Supreme Court ruling in Blanche v. Lau, issued on June 23, 2026, by a vote of six to three, broadened the scope of action for border agents regarding certain criminal records of permanent residents returning to the United States.

Immigration legislation states that, as a general rule, a permanent resident returning from a temporary trip is considered readmitted to the country.

However, it considers exceptions, including having committed certain crimes outlined in the legal grounds for inadmissibility, including those known as crimes of moral turpitude.

The Supreme Court determined that border agents do not need to have clear and convincing evidence of the commission of one of those offenses at the time of reentry to treat the resident as an applicant for admission.

The court did not determine whether the specific offense in the examined case belonged to that category.

The distinction is important because the legal reasons and applicable evidentiary rules in a migration procedure can vary depending on whether the individual is considered an admission applicant or a previously admitted resident.

It does not mean that any criminal record automatically results in the loss of a green card or deportation.

Certain crimes related to theft, fraud, or forgery may have immigration consequences, depending on their characteristics, the applicable legislation, and possible exceptions.

Therefore, even an old or dismissed case may require legal assessment before traveling.

Why should the Cuban community pay attention?

Numerous Cubans have obtained permanent residency under the Cuban Adjustment Act, and many travel to the island or to third countries. Documented cases show that old criminal records can also lead to problems when returning to the United States.

Erlan Rafael Arias was arrested in October 2025 at Miami International Airport after returning from Cuba.

His record included a petty theft charge from 2015, dismissed in 2017, and a 2016 case for conspiracy to steal mailboxes, for which he served probation.

After being detained for nearly a year, he was released in October 2026 and regained his permanent residency.

Another case is that of Yaima de las Mercedes Suárez, a Cuban mother of five and a permanent resident, arrested in February 2026 at Miami airport upon returning from Cuba.

His detention was related to previous charges of conspiracy and fuel theft from 2013.

According to the Department of Homeland Security, ICE carried out 483,200 deportations during fiscal year 2026.

On its part, an analysis by the Cato Institute estimated that the increase in arrests of Cuban immigrants was 463% between October 2024 and January 2026.

This latest statistic includes arrests of Cubans with various immigration statuses, not exclusively of permanent residents detained upon returning from trips.

What to check before leaving the country?

Immigration lawyers warn that having a green card does not eliminate the potential consequences of a criminal record when returning from abroad.

Although most permanent residents can travel without encountering these issues, those with criminal records, even if old or related to dismissed charges, should assess their situation before leaving the United States.

Among the main recommendations are:

  • Obtain the complete judicial record before traveling, including convictions, dismissed charges, archived cases, and documentation regarding compliance with sentences.
  • Consult an immigration lawyer with experience in criminal records to determine if any record may pose inadmissibility issues when returning to the United States.
  • Do not sign the I-407 form without understanding its consequences. This document is used to voluntarily renounce permanent residency. Your signature is not mandatory and signifies a waiver of the right to a hearing before an immigration judge regarding the abandonment of that status. If the resident does not agree to lose their residency, they may refuse to sign it and request a hearing.
  • Consider naturalization when legal requirements are met. Obtaining U.S. citizenship eliminates the risk of deportation due to immigration issues, although criminal records can also impact eligibility for naturalization.

Related videos:

Filed under:

CiberCuba Editorial Team

A team of journalists committed to reporting on Cuban current affairs and topics of global interest. At CiberCuba, we work to deliver truthful news and critical analysis.