Elections in Spain: Vox's proposals spark debate among Cubans about immigration and remittances

Santiago Abascal at a Vox rallyPhoto © Instagram / @santi_abascal

The proposals from Vox to tax remittances sent abroad and tighten access conditions for housing, healthcare, and social assistance for certain immigrants have sparked an intense debate on social media platforms on CiberCuba, where numerous users, including Cubans claiming to reside in Spain, expressed opposing views on the electoral program of the party led by Santiago Abascal.

The posts from Sunday, November 15, generated hundreds of comments and responses that reveal differences in the priorities of emigrants, their family ties to Cuba, and the influence of the island's political experience on their electoral preferences.

While some defend Vox for its rejection of communism and its proposal to give priority to Spanish citizens, others question the consequences that its measures could have on immigrants, including those who work, contribute, and support their families financially.

Anticommunism and the fear of repeating the Cuban experience

One of the most prominent lines of debate is the association some participants make between Cuban socialism and the Spanish left, especially the PSOE led by Pedro Sánchez.

A Cuban woman who claims to have arrived in Spain with Spanish nationality explained that both she and her family will vote for Vox because they do not want the country to end up in a situation similar to that of Cuba or Venezuela.

Other comments argue that Spain needs a political change and advocate for national priority proposals as a way to protect public services and prevent abuses in social benefits.

From that perspective, support for Vox is not necessarily interpreted as a contradiction with the status of being an emigrant, but rather as a decision related to the political experience of those who left Cuba.

However, other participants reject that association between the Cuban regime and the Spanish leftist parties. They point out the differences between both political systems and question whether anti-communism is sufficient to support any immigration proposal.

In one of the most significant exchanges, a user claimed that they initially sympathized with Vox but had changed their mind upon learning about its proposals. They criticized that, in their opinion, immigrants are primarily valued based on their ability to work and contribute economically, without considering situations of illness, unemployment, or family difficulties.

Remittances, social rights, and differences among Cubans themselves

The potential tax on remittances outlined in the electoral program of Vox sparked numerous interventions, especially from those who have family members in Cuba.

Some argued that every worker should be able to use the money earned after paying their taxes, including the option to assist their parents or other relatives abroad.

A participant explained that she does not need to send remittances, but she believes it is important to think about those who do rely on those payments to support their families.

Others questioned the practical scope of the levy, arguing that many Cubans use informal channels to send money to the island. There were also comments that confused bank fees or those of money transfer agencies with a state tax, even though these are different concepts.

The immigration restrictions sparked another discussion: the difference between those who already have Spanish nationality, those who hold legal residency, and those who are still trying to regularize their situation.

Several participants deemed it reasonable to require legal residency to rent a home or to limit certain benefits to Spanish citizens. Others reminded that many Cubans arrived in the country without citizenship and went through extended procedures before obtaining their documents.

There were also those who argued that Spanish nationality acquired by descent grants the same rights as that of any other Spanish citizen, and therefore, they rejected being treated as foreigners.

Among the more detailed comments, a significant distinction emerged: Vox's proposals regarding rental and healthcare primarily target immigrants in irregular situations, while others, such as reserving the Minimum Vital Income for Spaniards, could also affect foreigners with legal residency.

Distrust, accusations of manipulation, and discussion about the program

A significant portion of the conversation centered around the veracity of the published information.

Numerous users rated the proposals collected in the news as false, exaggerated, or taken out of context. Some accused CiberCuba of politically favoring the PSOE, while others suggested consulting Vox's program directly before forming an opinion.

There were also interventions that called for a distinction between what the party proposes and what could actually become law. They pointed out that an electoral program does not automatically take effect if a party comes to power; its implementation depends on political agreements, legislative processes, and legal constraints.

The exchange was accompanied by personal disparagements and, in some cases, racist insults and attacks against the national origins of other participants, especially when they defended opposing electoral positions.

Nevertheless, during the discussions, reflections emerged on the meaning of Spanish citizenship and the right of naturalized citizens to freely choose their political option.

One user argued that Cubans must accept the decisions made democratically by the Spanish, while others reminded that many emigrants are already Spanish citizens and therefore have full rights to participate in those decisions.

Cuba is also present in the Spanish electoral debate

The discussion even allowed room for reflection on the political situation of the island.

A participant expressed his hope that Cubans will one day be able to hold a similar debate about different candidates for the Presidency of Cuba, instead of merely observing and discussing the elections of other countries.

The reactions do not allow us to determine which party is predominantly preferred by Cubans residing in Spain. The comments on Facebook do not constitute a representative survey, and among those who participated, there are individuals whose residency, nationality, and voting rights cannot be verified.

They instead show a diversity of positions that prevents automatically identifying anti-communism with a specific electoral preference, or assuming that all emigrants share the same interests and priorities.

For some, the Cuban experience is a reason to support Vox and prevent what they see as a socialist drift in Spain. For others, that same experience serves as an argument to distrust the restrictions that could affect immigrants and families who are still facing challenges in settling in the country.

The debate also reflects an essential difference with the Cuban political reality: in Spain, those who have the right to vote can compare programs, publicly question their proposals, and choose between parties competing for power.

Related videos:

Filed under:

CiberCuba Editorial Team

A team of journalists committed to reporting on Cuban current affairs and topics of global interest. At CiberCuba, we work to deliver truthful news and critical analysis.