"I have a five-month-old daughter and she doesn't qualify": mothers report exclusions in food aid in Santiago de Cuba

Errors reported in food assistance listings leave mothers without modules in Santiago de CubaPhoto © CiberCuba

Several mothers with children under six years old and a pregnant woman reported that they were excluded from a food distribution module at the Red Market of Los Olmos in Santiago de Cuba, despite belonging to the eligible groups.

The complaints were collected in a video shared this Friday on Facebook by journalist Yosmany Mayeta Labrada.  The affected individuals pointed to the local delegate for alleged errors in compiling the beneficiary lists. They also attempted to contact a government official identified as Freya, but, according to the testimony recorded in the video, she responded that she was on vacation.

Capture from Facebook/Yosmany Mayeta Labrada

"Look at this little girl who is five months old and hasn't had her turn. Five months and she hasn't had her turn," one of the complainants is heard saying in front of the establishment, pointing to the baby.

The video also features a pregnant woman holding a child who claims she was left out of the distribution. "These people here don't want to give us the module because they say we're not entitled to it when they have done their job poorly," the complainant states.

Another woman directly accuses those responsible for the distribution of taking the food that is meant for her family. "I can personally tell you that my granddaughter is being robbed of everything that belongs to her. My daughter is a minor, and everything that is supposed to go to my granddaughter is being stolen," she declares.

The case adds to other concerns regarding the targeted social protection system that Cuba implemented in June, after replacing universal subsidies with a beneficiary selection mechanism included in a package of 176 economic measures.

Under this scheme, multidisciplinary groups from the popular councils classify individuals monthly to determine who receives the food modules. However, being part of a priority group, such as young children or pregnant women, does not guarantee automatic inclusion.

The authorities of Santiago de Cuba recognized over 101,000 vulnerable individuals in the province, more than 10% of its population. The module includes five pounds of free rice, sourced from a donation from China, one pound of sugar, and one pound of peas, the cost of which must be covered by the beneficiary.

In October, an elderly resident of Contramaestre reported that he was denied access to his local store because he had a daughter living in Brazil, while in Camagüey another elderly man was excluded from the subsidized oil sale for having relatives abroad.

In none of those cases was there a provision published in the Official Gazette that supported the exclusion criteria applied locally. There are also no known appeal mechanisms for those who believe their exclusion is unjustified.

This week, numerous Cubans responded with the phrase "here we are all vulnerable", following the announcement from the Ministry of Domestic Trade regarding the distribution of food modules for individuals in "greater vulnerability."

Similarly, elderly adults reported threats of losing food and pensions if they continued to receive food from opposition activists.

The Cuban Observatory of Human Rights estimated in August that extreme poverty affects 94% of Cubans. This figure stands in stark contrast to the just over 883,000 beneficiaries that the government acknowledges at the national level within its targeted social protection program.

Filed under:

CiberCuba Editorial Team

A team of journalists committed to reporting on Cuban current affairs and topics of global interest. At CiberCuba, we work to deliver truthful news and critical analysis.