Camila Ramos, a civil rights activist, was dragged across the floor, slammed against a sign, and shoved by several law enforcement officers during a tense session this Thursday of the Miami-Dade Commission, amidst a debate over the controversial agreement between the county jails and the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
The scene, captured on video by attendees, sparked immediate protests, shouts of “Let her speak!”, and ended with several confrontations between citizens and the police.
The moment of the explosion
Chaos ensued when the Commission's president, Anthony Rodríguez, warned attendees that if anyone chose to speak during the session, there would be no further opportunities for public comments if the issue was voted on again later.
Camila Ramos, 36 years old, was already near the podium and asked for clarification on that decision.
At that moment, an undercover officer ordered her to be quiet. She firmly refused: "I don't have to do this; I just need you to listen to me. I have the right to understand this process," she claimed as she approached the stand.
The response was brutal.
Several deputies from the Sheriff’s Office intervened and began dragging her forcibly through the premises in a struggle that caused her to collide with a sign and ultimately end up pushed to the floor of the lobby, while she repeatedly shouted, “Let me go! Stop! I just want to ask a question!”
The cameras and phones of the attendees captured the entire sequence.
Some attempted to follow the agents, which resulted in them also being forcibly removed, and in some cases, handcuffed.
A charged atmosphere
The day had already begun with a tense atmosphere.
The meeting at the Stephen P. Clark Center was characterized by the discussion of resolution 11A, which proposes to allow county jails to detain immigrants for up to 48 hours at the request of ICE, with a fee of 50 dollars per person to be covered by the federal government.
Although the matter was presented as a technical modification of the agreement, it actually deepened a collaboration that had been controversial since its inception, when it was implemented during Donald Trump's previous administration.
The mayor of Miami-Dade, Daniella Levine Cava, had signed the agreement earlier, which sparked criticism from organizations and activists.
“This is not a political choice, it is a legal imposition”, Cava stated before the commissioners. However, his explanation did not convince those who viewed this new step as a threat to transparency and due process.
Civil rights organizations fear that the "administrative disappearance" of detained migrants will be facilitated, making it harder for family members or lawyers to locate them within the prison system.
Arrests, charges, and protests
After her arrest, Camila Ramos was charged with aggravated assault and resisting arrest with violence, according to court documents.
The authorities claim that he struck an officer in the face during the struggle.
Z. Spicer, 25 years old, was also arrested after trying to interfere by shouting at the officers to let her go. He was charged with resisting arrest without violence.
The incident provoked an immediate reaction both inside and outside the venue.
Hours later, a candlelight vigil was held in front of the Federal Detention Center, where activists and community members denounced the repression and the humiliating treatment of Ramos.
"This is for all the people who essentially find themselves voiceless because they have been detained by ICE," expressed a protester.
Reactions and condemnations
The impact of the incident was so significant that the commissioners reversed their decision and reopened the opportunity for public comments, although the amendment to the agreement was postponed without a defined date.
The activist Dian Alarcón, present in the room, stated: “I have come many times and have never seen this kind of thing. I believe it is a way to silence us.”
Voices were also heard from the local government itself.
Commissioner René García stated that "the people have the right to their First Amendment," although he warned that "in this political climate, there will always be agitators from both parties."
Others, like Commissioner Roberto González, indicated that the agreement had already been signed in March, under legal obligation, and that it only remained to formalize the reimbursement mechanism.
Beyond the County: The Expanding Legal Framework
The episode highlights the effects of an increasingly expansive network of immigration policies in Florida, where the federal program 287(g) allows local forces to collaborate directly with ICE without the need for judicial orders.
Organizations like the Legal Resource Center for Immigrants warn that this promotes a systematic network of detention and deportation that jeopardizes the fundamental rights of millions of people.
In this context, what happened with Camila Ramos is not an isolated incident. It is the expression of a deep clash between hardened immigration policies and the fundamental exercise of civil rights.
As her lawyer summarized: “It was a blatant, arbitrary, and clearly intimidating act of censorship against a citizen trying to exercise her rights in a public space.”
Frequently asked questions about the arrest of Camila Ramos and ICE agreements in Miami-Dade
Why was Camila Ramos arrested at the Miami-Dade hearing?
Camila Ramos was arrested for attempting to ask a question about the agreement between the Miami-Dade jails and ICE during a county commission session. Her intervention provoked a violent reaction from the officers, who dragged and beat her, leading to protests at the scene.
What is the agreement between the Miami-Dade jails and ICE?
The agreement allows Miami-Dade jails to hold immigrants for up to 48 hours at the request of ICE, at a cost of $50 per person, covered by the federal government. This agreement has been criticized for enabling prolonged and non-transparent detentions of immigrants.
What were the consequences of Camila Ramos' arrest?
The arrest of Camila Ramos sparked immediate protests and reactions of outrage both inside and outside the venue. The incident forced the commissioners to reopen public comments on the agreement with ICE, although the modification of the agreement was postponed with no set date.
How does the 287(g) program affect the immigrant community in Miami?
The 287(g) program allows local agents to act as immigration officers after receiving federal training. This has raised concerns within the immigrant community, as it could increase distrust towards authorities and deter individuals from reporting crimes for fear of deportation.
What reactions have there been to ICE's policies in Florida?
ICE's policies in Florida have faced criticism and protests from activists and civil rights organizations. It has been pointed out that these policies encourage arbitrary detentions and violations of due process, severely impacting the rights of immigrants and creating a climate of fear in the affected communities.
Filed under:
